And with less than 2 minutes to go, with a lead of 18 points, the Buckeyes fell asleep, the Hoosiers scored 15 points in a span of 35 seconds, and the Buckeyes desperately needed to recover an onside kick (the second of two) to hold on to win 52-49 in Bloomington. Below are my observations.
- Devin Smith needs glue. It is becoming Smith's pattern to make the most ridiculous catches and then completely miss the easiest ones. Smith dropped two such easy passes in the game -- on the first, he committed the cardinal sin of turning his head to look for the endzone before securing the ball, and on the second he just...dropped...it. It went right through his hands, at which point even Braxton Miller turned around to view the replay to determine why his beautiful pass wasn't caught for a TD. Smith did score two long touchdowns though, one of which was mostly a result of his running skills after the catch, as he evaded a couple of defenders to extend the play. If the Buckeyes could figure out how to get this guy a little more consistent in his receiving abilities, his long threat could never be ignored.
- Commentators were AWFUL. I really don't like the BTN commentators. I know that they probably groan from week to week when they discover that they have to cover games that aren't supposed to be close, and they have to figure out a way to bring some excitement to the game. But it comes across as them rooting for the underdog, and last night it seemed like they were very excited for every opportunity that Indiana had to score on the Buckeyes. It also seemed a lot like Indiana "did something wrong" more often than OSU got credit for doing something really well. Combine that with the fact that they still can't seem to figure out how to properly execute commercials, and you miss at least one play a game, and they are often confused about what down it is, and it gets old fast.
- Officiating was atrocious. For the second week in a row, I was really confused and disappointed in the officiating. It wasn't that I would say the officials were biased. I am always reluctant to say that (at least, to seriously say that). But there were too many reviews and a lot of reversals. So by the end of the game, when there was confusion about whether Indiana recovered an onside kick that appeared to have gone out of bounds, all of the officials' credibility was SHOT. There were inconsistent calls all the way around, which makes it really frustrating to see something get called when it wasn't called on the same team earlier in the game. And as for the overturned reviews -- I think the replay official may need to look up the meaning of indisputable (not disputable or deniable; uncontestable. indisputable evidence; unquestionably real, valid, or the like), because at least one of the overturned plays did not show enough evidence to be overturned. Before you call me biased, I did agree with a lot of the calls that went against Ohio State early -- it just seemed like the whole thing deteriorated as the game went on.
- Carlos Hyde. Remember when we were worried about Jordan Hall's absence? Carlos Hyde has quickly transformed into such a presence on the field that I would be disappointed if Hall returned and Hyde wasn't still the primary back. He had a strong running effort for 156 yards against the Hoosiers. He runs his best when he just plows over defenders, rather than trying to dance around them. And when he and Braxton are in the backfield together, it really is a double-run threat, because either one of them can spring past defenders for extra yards. Though Braxton gets a lot of the offensive attention on the team, Hyde has become a very reliable runningback.
- Braxton Miller. Yet again, we see why Braxton Miller is such an asset to this Buckeye team. He rushed for 149 yards and 1 TD, passed for 211 yards and 2 TDs and 1 INT, and even jumped on a Rod Smith fumble to save a possession late in the game. But what impressed me most was watching how calmly he took the Buckeyes down the field after falling behind early. A lot of fans seemed to start panicking when the Buckeyes were down 14-10 after the blocked punt lead to a TD for the Hoosiers. And even when the Buckeyes let Indiana score again on the first possession of the second half, Braxton went out and took the offense down the field for a score, breaking out for a 67-yard touchdown run of his own. It seemed that no matter how many times Indiana scored, Braxton took his team on the field to answer, and the look in his eyes said everything -- he wasn't going to lose. He impressed me many times by making 10+ yards on wha seemed to be sure sacks, and that is one of the reasons his team must have so much confidence in him. My only concern is that early in the game, after the initial touchdown drive, the Hoosiers knew that OSU was going to run Miller, and they were able to stop him and even sack him many times. If Indiana's defense can do that, there will come a game (possible against Purdue or Penn State) where Miller's legs won't be able to save him. He gets better and matures as a leader and passer every game. If Devin Smith hadn't dropped 2 sure touchdown passes, we might be discussing Miller's arm more than his legs today. So if the Buckeye offense can continue to gel and get better, it will only help Miller in his rushing efforts. Just need to get that glue for Smith...
- HORRIBLE defense. It's hard to say that, because the defense has saved the offense at times this season, but in the last two games, the defense has surrendered 87 total points. I am beginning to get the feeling that OSU is more like West Virginia, and at some point they will not be able to score more points than their defense give up. But there are always those flashes of brilliance from the "Silver Bullets," points where I begin to think the defense is finally coming together. And there have been banged up players and injuries and young players. But I still had much higher hopes for this defense, with John Simon, Johnathan Hankins, Nate Williams (though banged up), and Bradley Roby than the amount of points surrendered has shown me. Coach Meyer isn't thrilled either, and it looks like Purdue may prove a tougher challenge than anticipated unless the defense can figure out a way to tighten up and shut down the passing game.
- Zach Boren at linebacker. Right along that theme of banged up players and figuring out how to shut things down, we got to see Zach Boren play at linebacker last night. I love Boren. I will just say that right now, because he is one of those players who will do anything that is asked of him. And giving him some experience on defense will only add to his resume should he be able to play at the next level. Having Mike Vrabel as a skills coach will also help in that regard, because Vrabel has played both sides of the ball in the NFL. Boren made some good tackles last night against the Hoosiers, though there were still gaping holes for the Hoosiers to run through on some plays. The only real downside I see of trying Boren out at linebacker is then we don't see him at fullback, and he might be one of our best blockers.
- Personal Foul penalties. Has there been one game yet this season where Ohio State didn't get some sort of ridiculous personal foul penalty? And when I say ridiculous, I don't mean that it shouldn't have been called. I mean one of those "WHAT-THE-HECK-ARE-YOU-THINKING-THE-PLAY-WAS-OVER-THAT-WAS-TOTALLY-UNNECESSARY?!?" type of penalties. It just shows a lack of discipline that I don't like to see.
- Kenny Guiton. I don't like to just complain, complain, complain. So let me talk about how excited I was to see Kenny Guiton pass for a touchdown! Another week brought another brief injury to Braxton Miller (following a late hit out of bounds, occupational hazard for a scrambling QB), and once again Guiton was called upon to come in and finish a scoring drive. What can I say about Guiton? It is refreshing to know the Buckeyes have him available if/when Miller goes out of the game. He is reliable and very capable, even if he lacks some of the flash Miller brings to the offense. And wouldn't you know it, Guiton had a few tricks of his own, completing a shuffle pass to Hyde for a touchdown! It was a great play, and it brings a confidence to the Buckeyes that when Braxton isn't in the game, it doesn't mean the offense is shut down.
- Corey Brown. I hear a lot of talk about Devin Smith in the media, because he makes long TD receptions (at least half the time) and is such a deep threat. But I don't hear nearly enough about what Corey ("Don't-call-me-Philly") Brown is doing in the Buckeyes offense. Brown often shifts into the backfield to serve as both a blocker and another running option. Braxton obviously has a great rapport with Brown as a receiver, because he throws him the option pass with ease and usually looks for him on those 3rd and long situations. Last night, Brown made SEVERAL clutch receptions on 2nd or 3rd down to extend drives. His sure hands are something any QB would value. He is a playmaker and deserves more credit than he is getting. Not to mention his punt return for a TD last week nor the fact that he covered up the final onside kick to secure the game last night. As far as receivers go, he is maturing quickly and I am excited to watch Miller and Brown grow together ike Smith and Ginn did for years.
- Corey Linsley. Speaking of players who don't get enough credit, the offensive line has been steadily improving of late. They have their issues at times, but aside from a few too many false starts (which seem to be plaguing the majority of the offensive linemen), I can't complain, because they are leaps and bounds above what they have been in past seasons. In particular, Corey Linsley has really impressed me with his blocking ability. He blocked TWO defenders on the shuffle pass from Guiton to Hyde, making the pass possible and opening up a hole for the TD sprint.















